Fussy Babies Don't Need Juice

A new study says parents of fussy infants tend to respond with juice, cereal, or other age-inappropriate foods.

January 13, 2011

It's tempting, but trying to solve this problem with some juice is probably a bad idea.

RODALE NEWS, EMMAUS, PA—As every new parent knows, that tiny addition to the family can cause a disproportionate amount of angst. But soothing fussy babies with juice or other foods before they're ready isn't a healthy solution, according to the American Association of Pediatrics. The AAP recommends that babies should be breastfed exclusively until 4 months of age, if possible, or fed formula if that’s not possible, and recommends that solid foods should only be introduced after babies are 4 months old.


THE DETAILS: Overwhelmed parents of fussy babies aren’t always sticking to those guidelines. A new study published in the journal Pediatrics followed low-income families in North Carolina to assess early infant-feeding patterns. Their findings? Though about 70 percent of the babies were fed at least some breast milk in their first month and 20 percent got breast milk exclusively, by age 3 months, things changed. Just 25 percent were being breastfed, and only 5 percent of the babies were getting breast milk exclusively. In addition, almost 20 percent of the babies were fed solid foods or juice by age 1 month; and by 3 months old, 70 percent were getting fed something (often fruit juice or added cereal) in addition to milk or formula. And the mothers who classified their babies as fussy were nearly twice as likely to feed them solid food early, compared with moms who described their child as calm.

WHAT IT MEANS: The concerns here are that not only do young babies not need solids or juice, but that those foods provide lots of extra calories. Infants fed these foods consume 100 more calories a day than infants given only formula or only breast milk, which can lead to babies who are overweight for their height. And sweet fruit juice may soothe a fussy baby in the short run, but establishing an eating pattern based on treating moods with sweets isn’t a good idea in the long run.

Though it’s easier said than done, overwhelmed parents can try other things to calm a fussy infant. For tips on soothing a baby without falling into the trap of giving them extra calories or age-inappropriate food, we turned to Daphne Miller, MD, a family practitioner in San Francisco and author of The Jungle Effect: A Doctor Discovers the Healthiest Diets from Around the World--Why They Work and How to Bring Them Home. Here are her suggestions:

1: Try gently massaging your baby. See our story Coax Any Cranky Kid to Sleep for techniques to try.

2: Take a walk with your baby and breathe in some fresh air.

3: Put on your favorite music and dance with your baby in a sling or a baby carrier.

4: If you’re breastfeeding, take a look at your diet and eliminate gas-producing foods like coffee, cruciferous veggies, and acidic foods, and see if that makes a difference. Sometimes avoiding dairy can also help.

5: Give your baby a couple of teaspoons of unsweetened chamomile tea.

Most important, says Dr. Miller, understand that this is a passing phase.

Next Up From Rodale Wellness

EPA Bans Toxic New Weedkiller
The "stacked" formula was designed to spray on GMO crops.
What Bee-Killing Chemicals Do to People
A breakthrough study suggests pollinator-killing neonicotinoids aren't safe for humans, either.
Top 5 Foods to Heal Digestion
Your leaky gut is begging you to eat these things.